It’s not often that I get riled up over things that happen in the news, especially in Canada. Yes, we have some outrageous things happening here, but for the most part, Canadian society is reasonably civilized.
However, a story that’s currently unfolding has me feeling a little sick. It is the story of Jian Ghomeshi, a popular radio show host who has just been fired amid a storm of allegations.
The short version of the story is this: Ghomeshi likes to engage in a form of sexual activity known as BDSM, which involves things like bondage, slapping and choking. If it’s not done with extreme care, a great deal of prior discussion, and constant monitoring of safety and comfort levels, it can be extremely dangerous. People can die from it. It’s not my cup of tea, but as long as there is complete consent and due safety, I really don’t care what other people do in the bedroom.
Ghomeshi’s sexual tastes became big news last week, when three women alleged that he had punched and choked them during these encounters, without their consent. He wrote an impassioned defense on Facebook, in which he claimed that he was a victim of a smear campaign initiated by a jilted ex-lover out for revenge. He admitted that some of his bedroom activities are controversial and offensive to some, but he insists that it has always been consensual. He states, in fact, that he can provide proof of consent.
Since the story first broke, more women have come forward, and there are now eight claiming that Ghomeshi has assaulted them. He is standing by his contention that he is being victimized, and he has launched a massive lawsuit against the public broadcaster that fired him.
Reactions to the story are predictably mixed, but what troubles me the most are comments being made by the staunch Ghomeshi supporters.
But he can prove that it was consensual…
If these women were really assaulted, they should have gone to the police and not the media…
They couldn’t have been victims, because they went back for more…
I know that there have been times when women have accused men of rape to be malicious, and that is despicable behaviour. If Ghomeshi is indeed telling the truth, he absolutely has the right to defend himself.
But what are these comments teaching today’s generation of young girls? That they are to blame if they become victims of ongoing sexual assault? Are we teaching our boys that they have license to do whatever they like under the umbrella of “kinky sex”?
I don’t have any daughters of my own, but I do have sons, and I want them to grow up with the following messages:
- If a woman gives consent, she is giving consent for what is happening in that moment. She can withdraw consent at any time, and you, my sons, have to completely respect that, no matter what is going on.
- The way a woman dresses or behaves does not grant you any entitlements. I don’t care if she’s walking around naked. You don’t engage in any sexual activity with her unless you are absolutely sure that it’s what she wants.
- If she’s drunk or under the influence of drugs, she is not capable of consent. Period.
- If you get involved with a woman who has been abused in the past, know that she is vulnerable. Just because she might have stayed with the guy for a period of time, that doesn’t mean she was OK with it.
- If you lose control of yourself and sexually assault a woman, don’t try to say it was her fault. It wasn’t. It was yours.
- If you rape a woman and she does not report it, that doesn’t mean she liked it. It is more likely to mean that she is afraid.
- Being involved in a relationship with someone does not give you license to do whatever you like with them. Your girlfriend/fiancée/wife is not obligated to have sex with you just because you feel like it. I don’t care if she’s been with you for ten years. If she says no, she means no. If you respect that, she is highly likely to say yes next time round.
- A woman’s prior sexual history has no bearing at all on whether or not she consents to sex. Whether she’s a virgin or someone who has had multiple sexual partners, no means no.
What messages would you want to give to your sons and daughters about sex?
This is an original post to World Moms Blog by Kirsten Doyle.
Photo credit: Brenda Lee. This picture has a creative commons attribution license.
I am the mother of three sons and absolutely agree with your guidelines. I am not familiar with the media story, but similar things have and do happen here. Great post, Kirsten.
I read this story in the news and hate the he said, she said sensationalism because you feel as though you will never know the truth. Sadly, with more and more women coming forward one errs on the side of where there is smoke there is fire – but who knows.
Personally, I cannot imagine wanting to be in that situation, but each to his own.
I have girls, and teaching them about what is and is not ok is part of my job. But life sure makes it hard to do that with all we are thrown. Perhaps my girls can date your boys?
Much love – great piece.
Absolutely PERFECTLY stated Kirsten!
Your points were spot on.
We are VERY strict about respect and good manners in our house. My 13 and 14 year old boys are very impressed with the way their father behaves towards me and their grandmother. They say that most of their friends dads don’t treat their wives in such a respecful way. In this my husband ISN’T typically Greek! Despite being the 21st century many Greek men treat women in a derogatory way. I think that one of the best learning tools we have is to educate by example and this will permeate into every area of our children’s lives.
Great post!
Great post Kirsten! So often “news” can be great teaching moments and I admire you for sharing these messages with your sons. While I recognize these types of conversations are difficult to initiate, they are so important to have with our children so they can be informed and empowered to make good decisions in the future. Thank you!
I think the biggest thing for us right now is to demonstrate respect for another person’s boundaries. When our son tells us to stop tickling, we stop. When we ask him to stop something, we expect him to stop right away. If he doesn’t, we have a conversation about how it feels to have someone doing something to our bodies that we don’t like.
Our hope is that if he learns to respect other people’s boundaries, he won’t feel entitled to overstep them some day…
You articulated the key lessons for boys/men so well. As a mother of sons, I’m keeping your list handy!